Cause List
| S.No. | Case No. | Subject | Case Type | Name of Appellant | Respondent | Next Date | Details | Order / Decision | Edit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16851 | 57/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Christ the King Nursery and Primary School | APFC, Trichy |
27/03/2025 28/04/2025 28/05/2025 30/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. C. Karthikeyan, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. The Representative Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for filing the Counter Statement. | ||
| 16852 | 57/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Christ the King Nursery and Primary School | APFC, Trichy |
27/03/2025 28/04/2025 28/05/2025 30/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. C. Karthikeyan, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. The Representative Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for filing the Counter Statement. | ||
| 16853 | 57/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Christ the King Nursery and Primary School | APFC, Trichy |
27/03/2025 28/04/2025 28/05/2025 30/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. C. Karthikeyan, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. The Representative Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for filing the Counter Statement. | ||
| 16854 | 56/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Primary Agricultural Co-op Credit Society | APFC, Madurai |
11/11/2024 24/02/2025 19/05/2025 18/08/2025 30/10/2025 17/02/2026 13/05/2026 |
The Counsel for the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. The learned Counsel for the Respondent is present. List to 13.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/Rejoinder if any. | ||
| 16855 | 56/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Primary Agricultural Co-op Credit Society | APFC, Madurai |
11/11/2024 24/02/2025 19/05/2025 18/08/2025 30/10/2025 17/02/2026 13/05/2026 |
The Counsel for the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. The learned Counsel for the Respondent is present. List to 13.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/Rejoinder if any. | ||
| 16856 | 56/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Primary Agricultural Co-op Credit Society | APFC, Madurai |
11/11/2024 24/02/2025 19/05/2025 18/08/2025 30/10/2025 17/02/2026 13/05/2026 |
The Counsel for the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. The learned Counsel for the Respondent is present. List to 13.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/Rejoinder if any. | ||
| 16857 | 56/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Primary Agricultural Co-op Credit Society | APFC, Madurai |
11/11/2024 24/02/2025 19/05/2025 18/08/2025 30/10/2025 17/02/2026 13/05/2026 |
The Counsel for the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. The learned Counsel for the Respondent is present. List to 13.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/Rejoinder if any. | ||
| 16858 | 56/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Primary Agricultural Co-op Credit Society | APFC, Madurai |
11/11/2024 24/02/2025 19/05/2025 18/08/2025 30/10/2025 17/02/2026 13/05/2026 |
The Counsel for the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. The learned Counsel for the Respondent is present. List to 13.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/Rejoinder if any. | ||
| 16859 | 56/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Primary Agricultural Co-op Credit Society | APFC, Madurai |
11/11/2024 24/02/2025 19/05/2025 18/08/2025 30/10/2025 17/02/2026 13/05/2026 |
The Counsel for the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. The learned Counsel for the Respondent is present. List to 13.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/Rejoinder if any. | ||
| 16860 | 56/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Primary Agricultural Co-op Credit Society | APFC, Madurai |
11/11/2024 24/02/2025 19/05/2025 18/08/2025 30/10/2025 17/02/2026 13/05/2026 |
The Counsel for the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. The learned Counsel for the Respondent is present. List to 13.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/Rejoinder if any. | ||
| 16861 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16862 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16863 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16864 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16865 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16866 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16867 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16868 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16869 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16870 | 60/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | The Tamilnadu Industrial Coop. Bank Ltd., | APFC, Chennai-14 |
18/09/2024 12/11/2024 23/12/2024 08/01/2025 20/02/2025 14/04/2025 27/05/2025 03/07/2025 18/07/2025 21/08/2025 |
Final Order - The Appeal stands dismissed on point of limitation. | ||
| 16871 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16872 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16873 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16874 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16875 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16876 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16877 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16878 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16879 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16880 | 55/2024 | 14B | EPF Appeal | Vidyasagar College of Arts & Science | APFC, Pollachi |
30/01/2025 07/03/2025 09/04/2025 09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 29/08/2025 26/11/2025 27/02/2026 20/05/2026 |
M/s. P. K. PanneerSelvam, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent filed the Counter Statement. M/s. Aishwarya, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. List to 20.05.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of wri | ||
| 16881 | 54/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Hindustan Institute of Engineering & Technology | RPFC-I (C&R), Tambaram |
06/08/2025 08/10/2025 14/10/2025 19/01/2026 17/04/2026 18/06/2026 |
M/s. M. Elanchezian, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. M/s. R. Vishnu, the Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. List to 18.06.2026 for filing the Counter Statement as last chance. | ||
| 16882 | 54/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Hindustan Institute of Engineering & Technology | RPFC-I (C&R), Tambaram |
06/08/2025 08/10/2025 14/10/2025 19/01/2026 17/04/2026 18/06/2026 |
M/s. M. Elanchezian, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. M/s. R. Vishnu, the Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. List to 18.06.2026 for filing the Counter Statement as last chance. | ||
| 16883 | 54/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Hindustan Institute of Engineering & Technology | RPFC-I (C&R), Tambaram |
06/08/2025 08/10/2025 14/10/2025 19/01/2026 17/04/2026 18/06/2026 |
M/s. M. Elanchezian, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. M/s. R. Vishnu, the Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. List to 18.06.2026 for filing the Counter Statement as last chance. | ||
| 16884 | 54/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Hindustan Institute of Engineering & Technology | RPFC-I (C&R), Tambaram |
06/08/2025 08/10/2025 14/10/2025 19/01/2026 17/04/2026 18/06/2026 |
M/s. M. Elanchezian, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. M/s. R. Vishnu, the Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. List to 18.06.2026 for filing the Counter Statement as last chance. | ||
| 16885 | 54/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Hindustan Institute of Engineering & Technology | RPFC-I (C&R), Tambaram |
06/08/2025 08/10/2025 14/10/2025 19/01/2026 17/04/2026 18/06/2026 |
M/s. M. Elanchezian, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. M/s. R. Vishnu, the Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. List to 18.06.2026 for filing the Counter Statement as last chance. | ||
| 16886 | 54/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Hindustan Institute of Engineering & Technology | RPFC-I (C&R), Tambaram |
06/08/2025 08/10/2025 14/10/2025 19/01/2026 17/04/2026 18/06/2026 |
M/s. M. Elanchezian, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant is present. M/s. R. Vishnu, the Counsel on behalf of the Respondent prays for time to file the Counter Statement. List to 18.06.2026 for filing the Counter Statement as last chance. | ||
| 16887 | 53/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Five Star | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 18/07/2025 15/09/2025 17/12/2025 25/03/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevanandham, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submission. | ||
| 16888 | 53/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Five Star | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 18/07/2025 15/09/2025 17/12/2025 25/03/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevanandham, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submission. | ||
| 16889 | 53/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Five Star | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 18/07/2025 15/09/2025 17/12/2025 25/03/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevanandham, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submission. | ||
| 16890 | 53/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Five Star | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 18/07/2025 15/09/2025 17/12/2025 25/03/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevanandham, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submission. | ||
| 16891 | 53/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Five Star | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 18/07/2025 15/09/2025 17/12/2025 25/03/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevanandham, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submission. | ||
| 16892 | 53/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Five Star | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 18/07/2025 15/09/2025 17/12/2025 25/03/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevanandham, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submission. | ||
| 16893 | 53/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Five Star | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 18/07/2025 15/09/2025 17/12/2025 25/03/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevanandham, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submission. | ||
| 16894 | 53/2024 | 7A | EPF Appeal | Five Star | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
09/05/2025 11/06/2025 18/06/2025 18/07/2025 15/09/2025 17/12/2025 25/03/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevanandham, the Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submission. | ||
| 16895 | 52/2024 | 14B & 7Q | EPF Appeal | AMK Athencottasan Muthamizh Kazhagam Man Power Service | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
10/02/2025 05/05/2025 04/08/2025 09/10/2025 08/01/2026 09/04/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevandham, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submiss | ||
| 16896 | 52/2024 | 14B & 7Q | EPF Appeal | AMK Athencottasan Muthamizh Kazhagam Man Power Service | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
10/02/2025 05/05/2025 04/08/2025 09/10/2025 08/01/2026 09/04/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevandham, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submiss | ||
| 16897 | 52/2024 | 14B & 7Q | EPF Appeal | AMK Athencottasan Muthamizh Kazhagam Man Power Service | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
10/02/2025 05/05/2025 04/08/2025 09/10/2025 08/01/2026 09/04/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevandham, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submiss | ||
| 16898 | 52/2024 | 14B & 7Q | EPF Appeal | AMK Athencottasan Muthamizh Kazhagam Man Power Service | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
10/02/2025 05/05/2025 04/08/2025 09/10/2025 08/01/2026 09/04/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevandham, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submiss | ||
| 16899 | 52/2024 | 14B & 7Q | EPF Appeal | AMK Athencottasan Muthamizh Kazhagam Man Power Service | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
10/02/2025 05/05/2025 04/08/2025 09/10/2025 08/01/2026 09/04/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevandham, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submiss | ||
| 16900 | 52/2024 | 14B & 7Q | EPF Appeal | AMK Athencottasan Muthamizh Kazhagam Man Power Service | RPFC-II, Nagercoil |
10/02/2025 05/05/2025 04/08/2025 09/10/2025 08/01/2026 09/04/2026 10/06/2026 |
M/s. T. Jeevandham, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Appellant prays time for Arguments. Time granted. M/s. R. Meenakshi, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Respondent is present. List to 10.06.2026 for hearing on Arguments/filing of written submiss |